Essay · By Stephen Pasquini
Seneca wrote to grieving friends more often than almost any other ancient philosopher, and he knew grief from the inside: he once mourned a friend so hard that he called himself a warning to others. His advice, gathered in two letters, is simple to say and hard to do: let the tears come, but don’t put your sorrow on display, and let the memory of the person you lost slowly turn sweet. Here is what he actually said, what still helps, and what to leave behind.
Seneca knew grief from the inside
Seneca is sometimes pictured as a cold man who told mourners to cheer up. The record is more human than that. Before his famous letters, he wrote three formal consolations, a kind of essay the Romans sent to people in mourning. The first, around AD 40, was for Marcia, daughter of the historian Cremutius Cordus, who was still mourning her son Metilius more than three years after his death. The other two he wrote from exile on Corsica: one to his own mother, Helvia, who was grieving his banishment, and one to Polybius, a powerful secretary of the emperor Claudius, whose brother had died.
Years later, in his letters to his friend Lucilius, he came back to grief twice. Letter 63 consoles Lucilius on the death of his friend Flaccus. Letter 99 is a copy of a letter Seneca had sent to a father named Marullus, whose little son had died.
And in Letter 63 he makes a confession. He had wept so much for his dear friend Annaeus Serenus that he had to count himself among the examples of people overcome by grief. Serenus was a younger friend to whom Seneca had dedicated two of his essays, On Tranquility of Mind and On the Constancy of the Wise Person. Under Nero he commanded Rome’s night watch, the city’s fire brigade, and according to Pliny the Elder he died, probably in the early 60s AD, after a meal of poisonous mushrooms. Seneca says the blow hit so hard because he had never once imagined that the younger man could die first.
Rule one: weep, but don’t wail
Seneca’s first rule is that tears are allowed. Even the ideal wise person, he says, feels a loss like this; for him it is a sting rather than a wound. The rest of us can be forgiven for crying, as long as we don’t let the tears run on forever. His summary is one of the best lines he ever wrote:
“We may weep, but we must not wail.”
— Seneca, Letter 63
He reaches back to Homer for support. In the Iliad, Achilles urges the grieving king Priam to eat, reminding him that even Niobe, who lost all of her children, remembered to take food. Grief is real, Seneca is saying, but so is the rest of life, and the body keeps asking for it.
In Letter 99 he goes further and refuses to ask for a stony face at all. Watching the burial of someone you love with the same expression you wore when they were alive, he says, would be a lack of feeling, not a virtue. Some feelings, he admits, simply have their own claim on us. Tears come whether we allow them or not, and shedding them brings relief.
Two kinds of tears
The most useful idea in Letter 99 is a distinction. Seneca says there are tears that fall by their own force and tears we choose to let fall.
The first kind come with the shock: the news, the funeral, the moment you hold someone for the last time. They are pressed out of us, he says, almost physically, and there is nothing to be ashamed of in them. The second kind come later, when we turn over the memory of the person: a voice, an easy conversation, the small routines of a day together. These tears have a sweet sadness in them. Seneca says we can allow them, even welcome them.
What he warns against is a third thing that dresses up as grief: tears summoned for an audience, or kept going because stopping feels like a betrayal. In Letter 63 he describes the mourner standing guard over his own suffering, keeping it sharp on purpose, as if letting it soften would prove he never loved at all.
Don’t perform your grief
Seneca is blunt about why some mourning goes on so long. We look for proof of our love in our tears, he says, and so we don’t simply feel sorrow, we display it. In Letter 99 he notices how few people are sad when they’re alone: they cry louder when they know they’re heard, and grow calm again when the visitors leave.
He isn’t mocking mourners. He’s pointing at a trap that most of us know. The crowd judges grief either way: if you bear it quietly, people call you cold; if you fall apart, they call you weak. Seneca’s answer is to stop asking the crowd. Grief is not a test you have to pass in public. You don’t owe anyone a performance, in either direction. The same habit of feeding a feeling by rehearsing it shows up in his advice on worry, where he says we suffer more in imagination than in reality.
Let memory turn sweet
Does this mean forgetting the person? Seneca expects Lucilius to ask exactly that, and his reply is gentle: a memory that lasts only as long as your grief would be a short memory indeed. The goal is not to forget the person but to change how remembering feels.
His old teacher Attalus used to say that remembering lost friends is like the pleasant sharpness of certain fruits, or the bitterness we enjoy in a very old wine. Seneca goes further. For him, the thought of friends who have died is simply sweet. He had them, he says, knowing he might lose them; and having lost them, he still feels he has them.
Letter 99 gives the reason this works. The future is uncertain and may never come, but the years you shared with someone have already happened, and nothing can undo them:
“The past is ours, and there is nothing more secure for us than what has already been.”
— Seneca, Letter 99
So he tells the grieving father to speak often of his son, and to recall the boy’s words and little jokes again and again. Grief that refuses to look back, he warns, buries your love along with the person you loved. Gratitude for what you had is not a betrayal of the loss. It is what the loss is made of.
Love the living greedily
The most practical line of advice in Letter 63 is aimed not at the dead but at the living. Enjoy your friends greedily, Seneca says, because you don’t know how long you’ll have them. Count how often you leave them for long journeys, or fail to see them even when you live in the same town, and you’ll realize how much of their time you lost while they were still here.
His own grief for Serenus taught him the hardest part: death keeps no order. The younger can go first. Anything that can happen on some day can happen on this one. That isn’t meant to frighten. It’s meant to send you to the phone. Call the friend. Make the visit. Say the thing you’d regret leaving unsaid.
What to leave behind
Not everything in these letters has aged well, and it’s worth saying so plainly.
Seneca sometimes treats grief as if it ran on a schedule, and he praises Romans who walked from a son’s funeral straight back to work. Today we know grief has no tidy timetable. It comes in waves, sometimes years later, and there is no deadline for being “over it.” His line in Letter 63 that it’s better to replace a friend than to weep for him sounds cold, even if his real point (don’t let grief close you off from new friendship) is a kind one. His remarks about women and mourning reflect Roman prejudice, not truth. And in Letter 99 he plays down the death of a small child in ways that would wound any parent who read them now.
Two things soften this. First, Letter 99 is explicitly not meant for fresh grief. Seneca says that someone struggling with a new wound should be comforted and allowed to grieve; his sterner words were for a man he thought had settled into mourning as a habit. Second, Seneca is honest about his own failure. The teacher who tells us not to wail admits he once could not stop. That honesty is what makes the rest of his advice worth hearing.
He also lived by it at the end. When Nero ordered his death in AD 65, Tacitus says, Seneca turned to his weeping friends and gently asked where their philosophy had gone. You can read that story in how Seneca died.
Seneca’s grief practices, in plain English
A note on grief today
Seneca’s letters can be good company in a hard season, but they aren’t a substitute for care. If grief feels unbearable, isn’t easing at all over many months, or keeps you from eating, sleeping or working, please talk to a doctor, counselor or grief support group. If you are having thoughts of ending your life, in the US you can call or text 988 any time, day or night. Seneca leaned on his friends in grief; you’re allowed to lean on yours.
Read the two letters this essay is built on: Letter 63: On Grief for Lost Friends and Letter 99: On Consolation to the Bereaved. For more, see our page of letters for grief and loss.
Frequently asked questions
What did Seneca say about grief?
In Letters 63 and 99 he says tears are natural and allowed, but grief should not be performed for others or kept going on purpose. Over time, he says, the memory of the person we lost can become sweet rather than painful, and we should be grateful for the time we had.
Did the Stoics think it was wrong to cry?
No. Seneca says that even the ideal wise person feels the sting of a loss, and that showing no emotion at a funeral would be a lack of feeling, not a virtue. What he warns against is excessive, performed or endless mourning.
Who was Annaeus Serenus?
A younger friend of Seneca’s who commanded Rome’s night watch under Nero. Seneca dedicated two essays to him and, by his own account in Letter 63, grieved for him so much that he counted himself among people overcome by grief.
Which Seneca writings are about grief?
Letters 63 and 99 to Lucilius, and his three consolations: to Marcia on the death of her son, to his mother Helvia during his exile, and to Polybius on the death of his brother.
Go deeper
The Penguin Classics selection of Seneca’s letters, a good companion to read slowly in a hard season.
Includes the Consolation to Helvia, Seneca’s letter of comfort to his own mother from exile.
One short Stoic passage a day, for when grief makes long reading hard.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.