Essay · By Stephen Pasquini
Read the first few letters of Seneca and you’ll notice something odd. Seneca, a Stoic, keeps quoting a philosopher from a rival school: Epicurus. Nearly every early letter ends with one of his sayings. So who was Epicurus, why was he supposedly the “enemy,” and why did Seneca love him anyway?
- Epicurus and his Garden
- Zeno, his Stoic rival in Athens
- Lucretius, the Roman poet of Epicureanism
- Seneca
Who was Epicurus?
Epicurus (341–270 BC) was born on the Greek island of Samos, just off the coast of today’s Turkey. His parents were Athenian settlers, and his father, Neocles, was a schoolteacher. So Epicurus grew up as an Athenian citizen living abroad, with a classroom in the family.
A boy who asked one question too many
He started on philosophy at about fourteen. The story ancient writers told is that his teacher read a line from the poet Hesiod saying that in the beginning there was Chaos, and young Epicurus asked: chaos came from what? When none of his teachers could answer, he went looking for people who could.
He studied first with a follower of Plato on Samos, then with Nausiphanes, a teacher in the nearby city of Teos who followed Democritus, the philosopher who said everything is made of tiny, uncuttable particles called atoms. That atomism became the backbone of everything Epicurus later taught. At eighteen he went to Athens for the two years of military service every citizen owed. While he was there, Athens lost a war, the Athenian settlers were thrown off Samos, and his family ended up as refugees in the town of Colophon. Epicurus joined them and spent the next decade reading, thinking and working out his own system.
How he earned a school of his own
There were no degrees or licenses for philosophers. You became a teacher by attracting students who would listen and stay. Epicurus did it the slow way. Around 311 BC, at about thirty, he started teaching in Mytilene on the island of Lesbos, where his ideas made enemies and he had to leave. He moved to Lampsacus, near the Dardanelles, and there it worked: he gathered a circle of loyal friends and students, among them Metrodorus and Polyaenus, along with Hermarchus from his Lesbos days. These were the men Seneca would name centuries later.
With that following behind him, and with help from his friends, Epicurus moved to Athens around 306 BC, the intellectual capital of the Greek world, and bought a house with a garden just outside the city walls. It became known simply as the Garden, and unusually for the time, it welcomed women and enslaved people as well as men. He liked to say he was largely self-taught, and he was famously dismissive of his old teacher Nausiphanes. He led the Garden for the rest of his life, about thirty-five years, and when he died in 270 BC he left the house and the school to his friends, with Hermarchus as his successor.
The Garden was less a lecture hall than a community of friends who lived simply and studied together. Epicurus wrote a huge amount, though only a few letters, sayings and fragments survive. His ideas spread across the Greek and Roman world for centuries; the Roman poet Lucretius later turned them into a famous poem, On the Nature of Things.
Epicurus or Epictetus?
Don’t worry if you mix these two up. Almost everyone does. The names differ by a couple of letters, both men were Greek-speaking philosophers, and both get quoted on the same websites. But they lived about four hundred years apart and belonged to rival schools. Here’s the quick guide (and the full story of the other one in Who Was Epictetus?):
When
Epicurus341–270 BC, Greece. About 300 years before Seneca.
Epictetusc. AD 50–135, Roman Empire. A generation after Seneca.
Who
EpicurusA schoolteacher’s son from Samos who founded his own school, the Garden.
EpictetusBorn enslaved in Phrygia; later a free teacher at Nicopolis.
School
EpicurusFounder of Epicureanism, the Stoics’ great rival.
EpictetusA Stoic, on Seneca’s side of the argument.
Big idea
EpicurusThe goal of life is pleasure, meaning calm and freedom from fear.
EpictetusSome things are up to us, some aren’t. Care only about the first.
And Seneca?
EpicurusSeneca quotes him again and again in the early letters.
EpictetusToo young to know Seneca. Neither ever mentions the other.
An easy way to remember: Epicurus gave us the word epicure (a person with refined taste in food and drink, a gourmet), even though he himself lived on bread and water. Epictetus is the one with the Stoic teacher in his name: he spent his life teaching Stoicism.
What did Epicurus teach?
Epicurus is famous, and often misunderstood, for saying that pleasure is the goal of life. That’s where we get the word “epicurean,” meaning someone who loves fine food and wine. But Epicurus meant almost the opposite.
- Pleasure means peace. The highest pleasure, he taught, is simply the absence of pain in the body and of anxiety in the mind, a calm state the Greeks called ataraxia.
- Keep it simple. Bread, water, a few good friends and freedom from fear were enough. Luxury, he warned, only creates new cravings.
- Friendship above all. He believed friendship was among the greatest goods of a happy life.
- Don’t fear the gods or death. He taught that the universe is made of atoms, that the gods don’t meddle in human lives, and that death is simply the end of feeling, so it’s nothing to fear.
- Live quietly. Stay out of politics and public ambition when you can.
Why were Stoics and Epicureans rivals?
The two schools grew up in Athens at about the same time and disagreed on big questions. Stoics believed virtue, not pleasure, is the only true good. They believed the universe is ordered by a divine reason, not random atoms, and that good people should take part in public life, not withdraw from it. For centuries the two schools argued, sometimes bitterly. (The whole rivalry, round by round, is in Epicureanism vs. Stoicism.)
So when Seneca, a committed Stoic and a powerful public figure, quotes Epicurus again and again, it’s a bit like a lifelong fan of one sports team quoting the other team’s coach. He knew it would raise eyebrows.
Epicurus and Seneca: who came first?
Epicurus came first, by almost three centuries. He died in 270 BC; Seneca was born around 4 BC. They never met, and the reading only went one way: Seneca read Epicurus, but Epicurus could never have read Seneca. (See the timeline at the top of this page.)
Here’s how the thread runs:
- Around 300 BC, two schools open in the same city. Epicurus teaches in his Garden outside the walls of Athens. A short walk away, Zeno founds Stoicism on the Painted Porch in the market square. The Stoic–Epicurean rivalry starts face to face, between two living teachers.
- The ideas travel to Rome. Both schools spread across the Greek world and then into Rome. In the first century BC the Roman poet Lucretius turns Epicurus’s philosophy into a long Latin poem, On the Nature of Things, and Epicureanism becomes fashionable among educated Romans.
- Seneca reads him in books. By Seneca’s day the Garden’s founders had been dead for centuries, but their writings were still copied and read. Seneca knew Epicurus’s letters and collected sayings well enough to quote them again and again, and he names Epicurus’s closest friends, Metrodorus and Hermarchus, too.
- Then he passes them to Lucilius. In the letters he wrote between AD 62 and 65, Seneca hands those sayings on to his friend, who leaned toward Epicurus. That’s why the old rival shows up at the end of so many early letters.
So the relationship isn’t a conversation between two men. It’s one man, three hundred years later, reading a rival school’s founder carefully, taking what he found true, and arguing with the rest.
Why Seneca quoted him anyway
Seneca explains himself early, in Letter 2:
“I’m in the habit of crossing over even into the enemy’s camp, not as a deserter, but as a scout.”
— Seneca, Letter 2
He had a simple principle: a good idea is a good idea, whoever said it. In Letter 12 he imagines Lucilius objecting, “Epicurus said that,” and answers that he’ll keep quoting him anyway, so that people who care more about who said something than what was said will learn that “the best ideas belong to everyone.”
There was probably another reason too. Lucilius, his friend and reader, was drawn to Epicurus. Seneca meets him where he is, using Epicurus’s best lines as a bridge toward Stoicism.
Epicurus’s best lines, as Seneca quoted them
Many of the early letters end with a short saying, a little gift for Lucilius to think about. Again and again, it comes from Epicurus:
“Poverty brought into line with the law of nature is great wealth.”
— Epicurus, quoted by Seneca in Letter 4
“If you live according to nature, you will never be poor; if you live according to opinion, you will never be rich.”
— Epicurus, quoted by Seneca in Letter 16
“If you want to make Pythocles rich, don’t add to his money — subtract from his desires.”
— Epicurus, quoted by Seneca in Letter 21
“Do everything as if Epicurus were watching you.”
— Epicurus, quoted by Seneca in Letter 25
That last one is Seneca passing on Epicurus’s own advice: choose a person you admire and live as if they could see you. Seneca liked it so much he applied it to himself, telling Lucilius in Letter 32 to live as if Seneca were watching.
Where Seneca disagreed
Seneca wasn’t a secret Epicurean. In Letter 9, he takes on Epicurus directly over friendship. Epicurus had said a wise person wants friends so there will be someone to sit beside them when they’re sick or help them in need. Seneca thinks that’s too transactional: a wise person makes friends for the sake of the friendship itself, to have someone to care for. Elsewhere in the letters he rejects pleasure as the highest good and insists on virtue instead.
Seneca also defends Epicurus from his own fans. In Letter 21, he says some people run to Epicurus for the wrong reasons, hoping his talk of pleasure will give them cover for their vices, when in fact Epicurus lived a strict and simple life. Seneca wants them to see that whichever school you follow, you still have to live honorably.
Why it matters
Seneca’s use of Epicurus says something about the kind of thinker he was: open-minded, practical and more interested in what helps than in whose team is winning. In an age of tribal arguments, that might be one of his most useful lessons. Take wisdom wherever you find it, even from the other side.
See Seneca’s “scouting trips” for yourself in Letter 2, Letter 4, Letter 9 and Letter 21. To meet the friend he was writing to, read Who Was Lucilius?
Frequently asked questions
Who was Epicurus?
Epicurus (341–270 BC) was a Greek philosopher, born on Samos to Athenian parents, who founded a school in Athens called the Garden around 306 BC. He taught that the goal of life is pleasure, understood as freedom from pain and anxiety, achieved through simple living, friendship and freedom from fear of the gods and death.
Did Seneca and Epicurus ever meet?
No. Epicurus died in 270 BC, about 270 years before Seneca was born. Seneca knew him only through his writings, which were still widely read in Rome.
What’s the difference between Epicurus and Epictetus?
They’re two different philosophers who lived about 400 years apart. Epicurus (341–270 BC) founded the Epicurean school, which taught that pleasure, understood as peace of mind, is the goal of life. Epictetus (c. AD 50–135) was a Stoic who was born enslaved and taught that we should focus only on what’s up to us.
Why does Seneca quote Epicurus so often?
Seneca believed good ideas belong to everyone, whatever school they come from. He also wrote to a friend, Lucilius, who was drawn to Epicurus, and used Epicurus’s best sayings as a bridge to Stoic ideas, especially in Letters 1–30.
What is the difference between Stoicism and Epicureanism?
Stoics see virtue as the only true good, believe the universe is guided by reason, and encourage public duty. Epicureans see pleasure (peace of mind) as the goal, see the universe as atoms and chance, and prefer a quiet private life. Both value self-control and freedom from fear.
Does “epicurean” mean someone who loves luxury?
In modern English it often does, but Epicurus himself lived simply and warned against luxury. His idea of pleasure was calm and contentment, not indulgence.
Go deeper
The Penguin Classics selection of Seneca’s letters. The best paperback to start with.
Seneca’s essays on tranquility and the shortness of life, plus letters.
One short Stoic passage and reflection for every day of the year.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
[…] Seneca disagreed with that order, but he respected the man. Letter 27 even ends with an Epicurus line: “Real wealth is poverty adjusted to the law of nature.” (More on that friendship-of-opposites in Who Was Epicurus?) […]